previous icon Back to blog
Sep 30, 2020
6 minutes read

The parts of customer service that should never be automated

Whenever self-service or customer service automation solves real problems for customers on their journeys to get their jobs done, its adoption soars. Just think about cash machines, and you see how this has been happening for decades, not just since Amazon started selling books online.

The discussion about which (parts of) customer service should (never) be automated has been around for a while. Ryan W. Buell, the UPS Foundation Associate Professor of Service Management in the Technology and Operations Management unit at Harvard Business School, published an excellent article on the topic.

There are several arguments he makes to highlight issues with the implementation of self-service. And there are some where we see evidence to the contrary emerge. Most of all, we believe Buell and many others are taking this from the wrong angle. How? Let's dig in.

Transformation is not without pain

Buell rightfully points out that self-service and customer service automation do not always result in the benefits companies want. On the contrary, with online banking implementations, many banks have seen an increase in customer service calls. He also mentions an example where patients who were adopting e-visits to the doctor paid more visits to the doctor.

Technological maturity, information ambiguity, and consumer maturity using automated and self-service are mostly to blame. Most of these problems will disappear in time.

We should not forget that where barriers to access disappear, customer service usage increases. Just think about how mobiles and smartphones have diminished access barriers to service. Call centers are always within reach with just one touch (or voice-command!).

Therefore, one should consider all these factors when planning to implement self-service and customer service automation. If you only look at gross numbers coming into the call center, they could well be telling you that your efforts to reduce live contacts are not working.

The best service is no service

You should always make an effort to understand why customers are contacting you and the volumes that are associated with those types of contacts. Furthermore, you should map these contacts in the value-irritant matrix you see below. This matrix is far from new. Bill Price, former VP of service at Amazon, explained how they developed their contact strategy based on this two-by-two matrix insights.  

value irritant matrix

Source: The best service is no service. Value-Irritant Matrix

When you do this, you can devise a strategy for each contact type, depending on where it sits in the quadrant. As you implement those strategies, you can easily track what is happening and explain any differences in contact volumes and their reasons.

Of course, one can debate whether automation is only a fit strategy for contacts in the right bottom quadrant. We believe automation (at least in part) should be part of the plan in each of the quadrants. Nevertheless, this is a useful framework to help you design a contact strategy and track progress.

"Customer Service can be emotional; technology cannot"

Secondly, Buell claims that technology can't be emotional, which must be a clickbait subtitle because service and technology are not total opposites. Technology is one of the competencies required to deliver a service. So yes, a service evokes emotions, and technology is partly responsible.

The valid point he's making is: "even if [technology] has the answers and can read the tone of our voice, or the expression on our face -people find the idea that technology "feels" and "senses" to be unnerving- and when a technology is deployed for such a purpose, the results can be unsettling." This is known as the uncanny valley:

The uncanny valley — the unnerving nature of human-like robots — is an intriguing idea. Both its existence and its underlying causes are under debate. We propose that human-like robots are not only unnerving but are so because their appearance prompts attributions of mind. In particular, we suggest that machines become unnerving when people ascribe to the experience (the capacity to feel and sense), rather than an agency (the ability to act and do).

When it comes to mimicking human behavior, from our experience, the uncanny valley effect holds when it comes to using avatars with human-like faces and "moving" expressions. They not only make us feel uncomfortable, but they also distract from the conversation itself. We humans expect technology to be functional and help us not to be like us. This is also why we advise communicating clearly to users when interacting with a (chat)bot.

But, it's also good to know that when bots express they are flawed, or do something unexpected, yet planned, in a funny way, people love it. It makes them giggle or laugh even. Maybe, over time, we will be entirely at ease when it comes to mind-reading robots. Or could it be we will accept it in the same way we accept much of the internet to be free in return for our privacy?

"We still prefer having people help solve our problems."

We disagree with Buell's statement here. Buell's main argument to support this claim comes from a 2012 research paper. As much as we believe the paper's facts, we think one cannot conclude that people prefer humans. The main conclusion one can draw from it is that people try to find other more effective ways to solve their problems if self-service didn't help them.

There is also quite some research that asks consumers whether they would like to interact with humans over machines or the other way around. Most of them conclude that many people prefer to deal with humans. But they seem to forget that people say one thing and very often do another. One of our clients even says it explicitly:

The unique thing is that in research, people say they prefer human contact over chatbots. We see them do the opposite.

And that's the thing. Year on year, we see interactions volumes with intelligent digital assistants, chatbots, etcetera, increase by over 50% on average. 

Consumers prefer self-service

We see the same trend with many of our clients. What we take from this is that consumers love self-service, done right. We even believe that they prefer self-service over live, human-powered service. They want to have a human option available at any time. They know automation is not at a level where it can completely take over tasks or deal with all the possible individual variations. But if they could, they would use it, without hesitation. They may say otherwise, but their behavior tells it as it is.

Human interaction is no longer the default

Despite nuanced differences of opinion, we mostly agree with Buell's four tips at the end of his article. If you haven't yet, read it. We also believe that we are yet to discover when human-to-human interactions can make a real difference. We haven't given it much serious thought because human interaction has always been the default. Now the coin has flipped; technology-driven interactions are the default today. We need to think about when humans should be designated.

Please try it out for yourself. And while you're at it, don't assume there are parts of the customer journey that should never be automated. If you want to add real value to human-to-human interactions, your starting point should be exactly the opposite: there are always parts of the customer journey that can be automated.

To get started with automation, check out our Chatbot page

Was this article interesting?
Share it!
connects tens of thousands of companies with millions of consumers via their mobile phone each day. Behind the scenes, from our innovative platform, makes sure companies can use these millions of messages, phone calls and payments to become part of people’s lives.

Latest articles

May 10, 2024 •

Happy clients, happy agents: The "platform effect" in customer service

As a member of the customer service team, you stand on the front lines of customer interaction every day. In a world where customers demand quick and personalised service - long wait times, impersonal responses, or worse, incorrect answers, can quickly drive a customer away. Your goal, however, is to connect customers with your organisation and deliver the best answers and service possible. It’s incredibly satisfying to see a customer leave a conversation happier and eager to purchase your product. Your efforts can significantly enhance the customer experience, but you need the right tools to truly excel. Integrating these tools into a platform amplifies your capabilities and lets you experience the power of the platform effect.

Mar 27, 2024 • Conversational AI

Navigating AI Adoption in South Africa

In this ever evolving landscape, businesses that proactively invest in AI capabilities stand to gain a significant competitive edge in the years to come. By embracing AI as a strategic imperative and overcoming the hurdles to adoption, South African businesses can unlock new opportunities, drive innovation, and position themselves for success in the digital era.

Conversational AI Cloud web conversations blog woman chatting chatbot
Mar 11, 2024 • Chatbots

6 steps to MSP profitability with AI Chatbots

As the Managed Service Provider (MSP) landscape continues to evolve, staying ahead means embracing innovative solutions that not only enhance efficiency but also elevate customer service to new heights. Enter AI Chatbots from – a game-changing tool that can revolutionise how MSPs interact with clients. In this blog, we’ll provide you with a comprehensive roadmap consisting of six steps to boost profitability using AI Chatbots from

Jan 15, 2024 • Mobile Service Cloud

What are the most effective customer service channels?

Today's diverse array of communication channels encourages customers to naturally gravitate towards their preferred social platforms and anticipate brands to be readily accessible across these channels. Rarely will customers go out of their way to switch between channels just to reach you; instead, they are likely to opt for a brand that not only provides the desired product but also ensures excellent customer service (on the channel they like most). How easily can your customers reach you via their preferred channel?

Education Technology
Nov 01, 2023 • Conversational AI

How AI Supercharges your Customer Service

Meeting customers' expectations remains the biggest challenge in service. Speed, convenience, and accurate responses are critical to achieving this. With the power of Generative AI, customer questions can be identified, categorised, and resolved more quickly. Plus, your organisation is continuously fed with data to improve the entire customer journey.

Jouw festival als eyecatcher
Oct 09, 2023 • Chatbots

The self-service revolution in customer support

Self-service is more than a buzzword; it’s a vital part of modern customer service that means your customers can get answers fast and your customer service team can focus on the issues that really matter. Allied to that, self-service can reduce costs and have a positive effect on the mental health of your customer service team. Not to mention the equally positive effect it has on brand perception.

Oct 06, 2023 • Chatbots

How to Use AI Chatbots to Improve Customer Service

Customer service teams encounter a broad spectrum of challenges in their daily operations. Customer expectations have surged to unprecedented levels, and the influx of repetitive inquiries can strain their patience and induce unnecessary stress. This phenomenon likely contributes to the relatively short tenure of customer service representatives, with an average job retention of just 12 months.

Oct 02, 2023 • WhatsApp

Chatbots in action, part 1: WhatsApp Chatbots

Facebook. Instagram. TikTok. There’s a rainbow of social media channels available to customers today. Some are visual; some are about connecting with friends; others are more business-like. But if there’s a single channel that spans communication in all its varieties, it’s Meta-owned WhatsApp.

Sep 28, 2023 • Chatbots

Chatbots in action, part 3: Facebook Chatbots

In the real world, people use different environments to achieve different goals. They’ll go to brick-and-mortar shops to compare prices and competitors. Visit a showroom to experience products up close. Or schedule a meeting to see a live demo. But is that how it works in the digital world? Yes, it is. The digital world has various environments, too, from websites to messaging channels, social platforms and more.

Is this region a better fit for you?
close icon